Judicial Insight

Dilemma · Ethics & Law

Sep 30, 2026 · Hypothetical, no court ruling

A police detective and a phone company representative debate unlocking a smartphone.AI illustration
Ethics & Law Dilemma

A kidnapping victim may still be alive. The only lead is a phone no one can unlock.

Should the phone company unlock the suspect's phone to help find a victim?
Victim still missingEncrypted phone1B users affected

TL;DR

  1. 1Police arrest a kidnapping suspect and believe the victim is still alive somewhere.
  2. 2The suspect's phone may show where, but it's encrypted and he .
  3. 3The phone maker says building a way in would weaken security for a billion users.

Should a court to break into the suspect's phone?

Be the first juror
Judge more cases