Judicial Insight

Everyday Law · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit

Sep 16, 2026 · 23-12854 · Appeal

A customer with a shopping cart faces a corporate representative in a retail store.AI illustration

Shoplifting dispute: Can a court pick which claims to judge?

A customer disputes claims against a major retailer in court.

TL;DR

  1. 1A man sued Walmart after a shoplifting incident led to his arrest.
  2. 2He says the court was wrong to judge some of his claims but not others.
  3. 3The case questions if a court can decide on only some state law claims.

Appeal

Lower-court ruling unlocks after you vote

Did the district court err by splitting its jurisdiction over state law claims?

Be the first juror
Judge more cases