Judicial Insight

Serious Crime · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit

Sep 18, 2026 · 23-30454 · Appeal

A symbolic image of shattered glass, representing a robberyAI illustration

Can this robbery defendant appeal his sentence despite a plea deal?

TL;DR

  1. 1The defendant pleaded guilty to robbery and waived appeal rights to avoid more charges.
  2. 2He later wanted to appeal, saying the court wrongly called him a career criminal.
  3. 3The Supreme Court says waivers can't cause a miscarriage of justice, but is this such a case?

Appeal

Lower-court ruling unlocks after you vote

Can the defendant appeal his sentence based on claimed calculation errors?

Be the first juror
Judge more cases